News
Supreme Court of India Warns Against Social Media's Threat to Fair Trials
The Supreme Court of India voiced concerns about individuals using mobile phones as media, potentially undermining fair criminal trials. The court's remarks came during a hearing about police posting images of arrested individuals on social media.
The Supreme Court of India has cautioned against the increasing trend of individuals using mobile phones to record and upload videos, which the court says poses a significant threat to fair trials. A panel of judges, including Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and Vipul M Pancholi, addressed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) that highlighted instances of police personnel sharing images and videos of arrested people on social media. The petition argued that such actions could prejudice public opinion, leading to negative reactions against the courts if the accused are acquitted for lack of evidence. The court agreed with senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan's observation that "every person with a mobile phone has become media", noting that people often prioritize recording incidents over assisting victims. Justice Bagchi noted that police departments have been given three months to establish standard operating procedures for media briefings to balance transparency, the right to information, and the accused's right to a fair trial.
Key Facts
- The Supreme Court addressed the risk of unfair trials due to social media activity.
- The court heard a PIL concerning police sharing images of arrestees on social media.
- The court noted that public opinion could be negatively influenced by social media posts.
- The court observed that people often record incidents instead of helping those in need.
- Justice Bagchi emphasized the need for a broader regulatory framework.
- Police departments have been granted three months to establish SOPs for media briefings.
- The aim is to balance transparency, the right to information, and the accused's right to a fair trial.
Primary Source
Research Sources
- Asianet News Network Pvt Ltd — 'Every Person With A Phone Is Media': Supreme Court Warns Against Social Media Trial